Shining a light on the Spotlight Effect

Have you ever done something completely embarrassing and assumed that everyone is staring at you, only to later discover that no one really noticed? The reality is that other people pay much less attention to you than you think. This is called the Spotlight Effect.

The spotlight effect is the tendency for people to overestimate both the degree to which they are observed by others and the degree to which others care about the things they do notice about them. This phenomenon was vividly demonstrated in a classic 1999 study in which student participants were asked to wear a bright yellow t-shirt with a large picture of Barry Manilow’s head to an introductory psychology class. The participants predicted that 50% of the other students in the lecture would notice their embarrassing t-shirt but, in fact, only 25% of their classmates actually remembered seeing it.

The researchers recreated the experiment using t-shirts with less embarrassing faces (i.e. Jerry Seinfeld, Martin Luther King, Jr., or Bob Marley) and found the same results.

Students wearing the shirt greatly overestimated the percentage of others who actually remembered it.

The spotlight effect is not limited to visual memory but equally applies to auditory memory. The same researchers divided student participants into groups to discuss “the problem of inner cities in the U.S.” and to draft a policy statement with their recommendation. Afterwards, the participants were asked to write down the five most remarkable comments made during the discussion – either good or bad. As expected by the spotlight effect, participants mentioned their own good and bad comments much more frequently than other people remembered them.

The spotlight effect is to be expected because we interpret every situation based on our own biases and experiences. If we notice something, we assume that everyone else would notice it as well. And, if we interpret it as bad or embarrassing, we assume that others will also. However, everyone else is a product of their own biases and experiences – they are much more likely paying attention to their world and not noticing yours!

So, the next time you think the world is shining a spotlight on a mistake you have made, relax. It is much more likely that no one noticed.


3 Responses to Shining a light on the Spotlight Effect

  1. Ross Carter June 29, 2020 at 5:06 am #

    Thought maybe that was one of your shirts from high school! 🙂

  2. Margaret Isley Wimmer July 4, 2020 at 7:51 am #

    I went to high school with Jon. He absolutely did not have that shirt.

  3. Jennifer Doss August 7, 2020 at 10:20 am #

    Great post!

Leave a Reply